|Menthol, billed as a "Cough Suppressant/Oral Anesthetic"|
But what is menthol? Why does it make your throat feel cool? How does it work? Let's take a quick look at an ancient medicine that we have only recently begun to understand. Read on....
Menthol has been used for hundreds of years as a treatment for rhinitis (runny nose), congestion, and cough. Menthol has also been used for centuries in folk medicine to relieve pain and itching. It is most commonly found in plants of the Lamiaceae (mint) family, specifically the Mentha genus that contains peppermint (Mentha piperita), spearmint (Mentha spicata), and corn mint (Mentha arvensis; a major source of industrial menthol production), among others. It is thought that peppermint has been grown and used for medicinal purposes in Japan for at least 2000 years.
Purified menthol was first isolated from oil of peppermint plants (species Mentha piperita) in 1771 by the German-born physician and chemist Hieronymus David Gaubius, who called it camphora europaea menthae piperitidis. By the end of the 1700s, world-wide consumption of mint oils was estimated to be only about one thousand kilograms per year. By the end of the 1800s, that number jumped to 175 thousand kilograms. Today, we consume about 26 million kilograms of peppermint oils annually. The actual amount of menthol consumed is thought to be about 6 million kilograms(7000 tons), an amount valued at more than $300 million that is then sold in many types of products that generate billions of dollars of further revenue. With all of the cold, flu, and pain-relief products that contain menthol, menthol production is big business.
|Structure of menthol|
Menthol is a cyclic terpene alcohol that is a solid at room temperature but melts into a liquid at slightly higher temperatures, making it a perfect ingredient for things like cough drops, lip balms, and topical creams that need to be solid or semi-solid at room temperature.
Many people find relief in the pleasant "cool" sensation that menthol stimulates, but menthol doesn't actually cool anything. It took well over 200 years from Gaubius's isolation of menthol to our understanding of how it actually works. Menthol doesn't actually lower the temperature. It just has the unique property of making you feel "cool" the same way that capsaicin in chili peppers makes you feel "hot." It effectively tricks you senses. In 1886, a scientist named Goldscheider presented some of his studies on menthol at a meeting of the Physiological Society of Berlin. At the time, many people thought that the cooling effect of menthol on the skin had something to do with its evaporation (we previously discussed evaporative cooling here). Goldscheider found that menthol application did not decrease surface temperature, and he attributed the cooling sensation of menthol to the activation "thermoreceptors" in "special nerves of temperature." It wasn't until 1978 that it was more clearly shown that menthol indeed activates sensory nerves. Through this activation of sensory nerves, menthol has been proposed to exerts affects on breathing, thirst, and alertness.
|Menthol as an active ingredient in a topical rub.|
TRMP8 is a temperature-regulated ion channel that is activated along a temperature range from cool (26° C [79 °F]) to cold (less than 15° C [56 °F]). An ion channel is a protein in the membrane of a cell (we discussed a bit about biological membranes here) that allows the passage of charged atoms or molecules (ions). Ion channels are almost always regulated; that is, the cell can control whether they are predominately open or closed. Stimulation of TRPM8 opens the ion channel and allows influx of calcium ions (an important ion in cell signaling) into the nerve cell, resulting in nerve depolarization and stimulation of an electrical signal (called an action potential) that transmits sensory signals to the brain. In addition to temperature, TRPM8 is also activated directly by the menthol found in oils from plants like peppermint, corn mint, and eucalyptus. By activating TRPM8, menthol "tricks" your sensory nerves into thinking that they've gotten "cooler."
TRPM8 activation can be either analgesic (pain relieving) or pro-algesic (pain causing). Some people with chronic pain and some chemotherapy patients can develop a hypersensitivity to cold (called "cold allodynia"), and TRPM8 blockers (antagonists) may have important therapeutic potential. This is an area of active research, as both Bayer Healthcare and Janssen Pharmaceuticals have developed, patented, and published on TRPM8 antagonists (patents WO2006040103 and US20100160337, respectively).
|Mouthwash label showing menthol as an active ingredient.|
|Lots of cold products contain menthol.|
While menthol is ubiquitously used in cough drops and syrups as well as nasal sprays to relieve congestion and nasal irritation, recent studies have actually shown that menthol does not significantly increase nasal air flow. Some studies have shown that menthol actually increases congestion. Instead, the feeling of cold in the nose may provide a false sense of improved breathing that nonetheless may still be important by providing a sense of symptom relief.
Menthol has also long been used for its antitussive (cough-suppressing) effects, and recent scientific studies show that it does indeed suppress coughing. Coughing is a protective reflex that protects your airways by forcefully expelling excess mucus or harmful vapors or irritants from the lungs. Millions of dollars are spent yearly on over-the-counter cough suppressants, though many have been shown to be no better than honey or other sugary syrups, which alone can suppress coughing. Menthol and sucrose (sugar) are two of the only things that have been legitimately shown to suppress the cough reflex, but we don't yet fully understand how either of these actually work. However, that means the time-honored cough remedies like menthol cough drops and hot tea with sugar or honey are just as valid therapeutics as more expensive cough syrups.
The dark side of menthol
Not all the uses of cool minty menthol are beneficial, though. Menthol has been added to cigarettes since the late 1920s. This resulted from an accidental creation of the first mentholated cigarettes by an Ohio man named Lloyd "Spud" Hughes in 1924. He stored some cigarettes in a tin container of menthol crystals. When he smoked them, he was pleasantly surprised, and in 1927, the Axton-Fisher Tobacco Company started producing "Spud Menthol Cooled Cigarettes," which were the fifth most popular cigarette brand by 1932. Many other companies followed suite and began producing their own brands of menthol cigarettes.
|Cigarette smoke contains irritants that are masked by menthol.|
In March of 2011, the US FDA's Tobacco Products Scientific Advisory Committee (TPSAC) concluded that "removal of menthol cigarettes would benefit public health in the United States," though the committee did not overtly recommend a ban or recommend any plan to reduce menthol cigarette use. While candy-flavored cigarette additives are banned by the FDA, menthol continues to be used. Some groups, including law enforcement groups, feel that the popularity of menthol cigarettes is so high that banning them could create a "black market" for smuggling or making mentholated cigarettes and actually do more harm than good. However, in June of 2013, the European Union officially agreed to ban mentholated cigarettes to specifically prevent young people from becoming addicted to tobacco. Whether the US ever follows suite and proposes a similar ban remains to be seen. It is clearly a complicated issue, and the pros and cons of such a ban must be considered.
A final note
While menthol is generally considered to be safe by the FDA, high concentrations of menthol can cause acute localized allergic reactions like rash or more systemic allergic reactions like respiratory difficulty and asthmatic reactions. It is thought that over-activation of TRPM8 can also least to symptoms of asthma, causing airway constriction and mucus production. If you are going to use a product containing menthol, please use it only in line with the manufacturer's instructions and consult with your doctor first. Nothing that you read on the internet (including TheMadScienceBlog) is ever a good substitute for real professional medical advice.
Text © 2013 TheMadScienceBlog; Images are public domain.
Sources and further reading:
- S.J. Anderson. "Menthol cigarettes and smoking cessation behaviour: a review of tobacco industry documents." Tobacco Control. 2011. 20(Suppl 2):ii49-ii56. doi:10.1136/tc.2010.041947 Available here.
- S.J. Anderson. "Marketing of menthol cigarettes and consumer perceptions: a review of tobacco industry documents." Tobacco Control. 2011. 20(Suppl 2):ii20-ii28. doi:10.1136/tc.2010.04193 Available here.
- N. L. Benowitz and J.M. Samet. "The Threat of Menthol Cigarettes to U.S. Public Health." New England Journal of Medicine. 2011. 364:2179-2181. Available here.
- J.-D. Brederson, P.R. Kym, and A. Szallasi. "Targeting TRP channels for pain relief." European Journal of Pharmacology. 2013. In Press. doi: 10.1016/j.ejphar.2013.03.003
- A. Burrow, R. Eccles, A.S. Jones. "The effects of camphor, eucalyptus and menthol vapors on resistance to airflow and nasal sensation." Acta Otolaryngology. 1983. 96:157–61.
- P.V. Dicpinigaitis. "Currently available antitussives." Pulmonary Pharmacology and Therapeutics. 2009. 22:148–151.
- P.V. Dicpinigaitis. "Review: Effect of drugs on human cough reflex sensitivity to inhaled capsaicin. Cough. 2012. 8:10. Available here.
- R. Eccles. "Role of cold receptors and menthol in thirst, the crave to breathe and arousal." Appetite. 2000. 24:29-35.
- R. Eccles, "Menthol: Effects on Nasal Sensation of Airflow and the Drive to Breathe." Current Allergy and Asthma Reports. 2003. 3:210–214.
- R. Eccles, D.H. Griffiths, C.G. Newton, and N.S. Tolley. "The effects of D and L isomers of menthol upon nasal sensation of airflow." The Journal of Laryngology and Otology. 1988. 102:506-508.
- R. Eccles, M.S. Jawad, and S. Morris. "The effects of oral administration of (-)-menthol on nasal resistance to airflow and nasal sensation of airflow in subjects suffering from nasal conges- tion associated with the common cold." J Pharm Pharmacol. 1990. 42:652–654.
- R. Eccles, B. Lancashire, and N.S. Tolley. "The effect of aromatics on inspiratory and expiratory nasal resistance to airflow." Clin Otolaryngol. 1987. 12:11–14.
- R. Eccles, S. Morris, and M.S. Jawad. "The effects of menthol on reaction time and nasal sensation of airflow in subjects suffering from the common cold." Clin Otolaryngol. 1990. 15:39-42.
- N. Galeotti, L.D.C. Mannelli, G. Mazzanti, A. Bartolini, and C. Ghelardini. "Menthol: a natural analgesic compound." Neuroscience Letters. 2002. 322:145–148.
- S. Garten and R.V. Falkner. "Continual smoking of mentholated cigarettes may mask the early warning symptoms of respiratory disease." Preventive Medicine. 2003. 37:291–296
- G.A. Giovino, S. Sidney, J.C. Gfroerer, P.M. O'Malley, J.A. Allen, P.A. Richter, et al. "Epidemiology of menthol cigarette use." Nicotine Tobacco Research. 2004. 6(Suppl. 1):S67–81.
- M.S. Grace, E. Dubuis, M.A. Birrell, and M.G. Belvisi. "Pre-clinical studies in cough research: Role of Transient Receptor Potential (TRP) channels." Pulmonary Pharmacology and Therapeutics. 2013. In Press. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.pupt.2013.02.007
- V.B. Journigan and N.T. Zaveri. "TRPM8 ion channel ligands for new therapeutic applications and as probes to study menthol pharmacology." Life Sciences. 2013. 92:425-37. doi: 10.1016/j.lfs.2012.10.032.
- K. Klausner. "Menthol cigarettes and smoking initiation: a tobacco industry perspective." Tobacco Control. 2011. 20(Suppl 2):ii12-ii19. doi:10.1136/tc.2010.041954 Available here.
- W.M. Knowlton and D.D. McKemy. "TRPM8: From Cold to Cancer, Peppermint to Pain." Current Pharmaceutical Biotechnology. 2011. 12:68-77. Available here.
- J.M. Kreslake, G.F. Wayne, H.R. Alpert, H.K. Koh, and G.N. Connolly. "Tobacco Industry Control of Menthol in Cigarettes and Targeting of Adolescents and Young Adults." American Journal of Public Health. 2008. 98:1685-1692. Available here.
- P.N. Lee. "Systematic review of the epidemiological evidence comparing lung cancer risk in smokers of mentholated and unmentholated cigarettes." BMC Pulmonary Medicine. 2011. 11:18. doi:10.1186/1471-2466-11-18. Available here.
- Y.O. Lee and S.A. Glantz. "Menthol: putting the pieces together." Tobacco Control. 2011. 20(Suppl 2):ii1-ii7. doi:10.1136/tc.2011.043604 Available here.
- J. Lindemann, E. Tsakiropoulou, M.O. Scheithauer, I. Konstantinidis, K.M. Wiesmiller. "Impact of menthol on nasal mucosal temperature and nasal patency." American Journal of Rhinology. 2008. 22, 402–405.
- K. Naito, M. Komori, Y. Kondo, M. Takeuchi, and S. Iwata. "The effect of L-menthol stimulation of the major palatine nerve on subjective and objective nasal potency." Auris Nasus Larynx. 1997. 24:159-162.
- T. Patel, Y. Ishiuji, MD, and G. Yosipovitch. "Menthol: A refreshing look at this ancient compound." Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology. 2007. 57:873-878.
- J. Plevkova, M. Kollarik, I. Pliacek, M. Brozmanova, L. Surdenikova, M. Tartar, N. Mori, and B.J. Canning. "The role of trigeminal nasal TRPM8 expressing afferent neurons in the antitussive effects of menthol." Journal of Applied Physiology. 2013. In Press. doi:10.1152/japplphysiol.01144.2012
- L.S. Premkumar and M. Abooj. "TRP channels and analgesia." Life Sciences. 2013. 92:415-424.
- J.M. Samet, M.S. Clanton, K.L. DeLeeuw, D.K. Hatsukami, J.E. Henningfield, J.H. Lauterbach, et al. "Menthol cigarettes and public health: review of the scientific evidence and recommendations." Tobacco Products Scientific Advisory Committee. 2011. Available here (link opens PDF).
- L. Tsavaler, M.H. Shapero, S. Morkowski, and R. Laus. "Trp-p8, a novel prostate-specific gene, is up- regulated in prostate cancer and other malignancies and shares high homology with transient receptor potential calcium channel proteins." Cancer Research. 2001. 61:3760–9. The original paper where TRPM8 was cloned, available here.
- D.N. Willis, B. Liu, M.A. Ha, S.E. Jordt, and J.B. Morris. "Menthol attenuates respiratory irritation responses to multiple cigarette smoke irritants." The FASEB Journal. 2011. 25:4434–44. Available here.
- P.M. Wise, P.A.S. Breslin, and P. Dalton. "Sweet taste and menthol increase cough reflex thresholds." Pulmonary Pharmacology and Therapeutics. 2012. 25:236-241.